96kps biochips
Login
96kps biochips
Login
System Apps
Directory
Help
Hexit
Language
QRator
Random Channel
Report Bug
Search
Support Hubzilla
2026-09-10 21:40:16
View Profile
Ben Pate 🤘🏻
via
Torsten Torsten
benpate@mastodon.social
Hey
#Fediverse
.. I need to ask you a controversial question about
#AI
.
My software (including bandwagon.fm) hard blocks anything it can identify as an AI agent. It's the best blocking mechanism I could find, and it is important for artists who feel like their music is getting stolen by AI scrapers.
But AI is becoming the way that many/most people search the Internet, so that hard block makes you increasingly invisible to people searching the Internet.
What do YOU think we should do?
Let Users Opt-In to Allow AI Scrapers
14 Votes | 13%
Opt-In + Limit Text Differently From Attachments
10 Votes | 9%
Keep The Mandatory Block. No AI Ever
82 Votes | 73%
Something Else (Elaborate in Comments)
6 Votes | 5%
112 Votes in total
Poll has ended
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:41:55
View Profile
FediThing :progress_pride:
FediThing@social.chinwag.org
@benpate
When people use AI to search the internet, they're generally not visiting the places the AI scraped but just reading what the AI has scraped from those places 😞
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:42:24
View Profile
Scott Jenson
scottjenson@social.coop
@benpate
Can you allow the text content but block audio access? Kind of split the difference?
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:42:31
View Profile
Steffen Voß
kaffeeringe@social.tchncs.de
@benpate
Good question...
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:42:49
View Profile
Kent Navalesi ☕️
KentNavalesi@mstdn.social
@benpate
Are people really using chatbots as search engines? my god . . .
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:47:00
View Profile
Johnny Than
johnnythan@tuebingen.network
@benpate
Every step towards normalizing AI is a step to normalizing AI. Please don't. :)
Be the counterrevolution.
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:48:39
View Profile
eclexic
theeclecticdyslexic@mstdn.social
@benpate
Being scraped for inference does not suggest that the person receiving that output of that inference will come to your site. I highly doubt allowing agents will result in increased human traffic. If we are talking genuinely agenetic operation here, there isn't even going to be someone seeing the output, let alone following it to the site.
I think unblocking them will likely just increase hosting costs.
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:50:50
View Profile
wordsmith‽ ⁂
wordsmith@writing.exchange
@benpate
I think there are times and contexts for compromise, and others where one must uphold a principle unwaveringly. Slop is so extremely harmful and abusive, in so many aspects from its very fundaments, that I believe we must say "No AI ever."
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:59:02
View Profile
Default Media Transmitter
defaultmediatransmitter@social.bitwig.community
@benpate
I view bandwagon as a part of the non-corporate internet built by and for people. If someone uses "AI" to search the internet, they are outside of this effort, and I don't think you should cater to them.
(I generally don't want to tell you what to do with your own project, but you asked 😀)
Link to Source
2026-09-10 21:59:58
View Profile
𝗗𝗮𝗿𝗸𝘸𝘰𝘭𝘧
darkwolf@hear-me.social
@benpate
I can't speak for anyone else, but I'm totally fine with AI not being able to find me. I prefer it that way, and I'm thankful for any platform available to take a stand against it.
Link to Source
2026-09-10 22:02:44
View Profile
bloodless girls
bloodlessgirls@musicians.today
@benpate
As an artist on Bandwagon (
https://bandwagon.fm/@bloodlessgirls
) I fully support the hard ban on AI crawlers.
1
Link to Source
Expand Replies
2026-09-10 22:03:16
View Profile
Bionicle Bunny
technocrow@blahaj.zone
@benpate@mastodon.social
as an artist I can say that discoverability is
important
, but not
that
important.
ultimately unless you have a distributor, online discovery isnt the primary method most people use to get the word out. personally, 15 years in industry of making art has shown me that word of mouth locally goes far farther than online discoverability.
Link to Source
2026-09-10 22:06:25
View Profile
Emma Needs ☕️
emma@orbital.horse
@benpate
people using AI to search the internet deserve the same gulag the people running the AI scrapers get sent to.
Link to Source
2026-09-10 22:14:57
View Profile
Tim Lavoie
tim_lavoie@cosocial.ca
@benpate
I like the bot-poisoning ideas that
@algernon
has put into iocaine. While nobody will ever care, I plan to implement something along those lines myself.
Link to Source
2026-09-10 22:20:38
View Profile
A former GPL zealot
algernon@come-from.mad-scientist.club
@benpate
Being invisible to AI search engines is a feature. They do not drive traffic to my site anyway: at
best
they regurgtitate what they scraped.
No thanks.
People can find my software and other things through the Fediverse, word of mouth, or my Codeberg mirror. I have been pretty much invisible to the major search engines for
years
at this point, and I'm yet to see a downside.
Link to Source
2026-09-10 22:37:13
View Profile
slowclap 👏
slowclap@social.smplfi.com
@benpate
I don’t think you’d ever need to allow scraping by an ai agent of the content within your site, keep artists protected, but potentially, at most, consider allowing scraping the existence of the site, like just your / or marketing copy or whatever.
Hopefully your software provides the means for discoverability within it. Which will be superior to whatever AI would offer in that regard anyways.
I also think more and more we’re going to see a divide between people looking for information and looking for community / art / writing etc. AI may be useful for information but it’s horrible for connection!
Link to Source
2026-09-10 22:37:16
View Profile
Ray McCarthy
raymaccarthy@mastodon.ie
@benpate
Loads of people use non-AI search, which returns real results.
Many use Qwant.
1
Link to Source
Expand Replies
2026-09-10 23:08:26
View Profile
*jayrope
jrp@hub.kliklak.net
@Ray McCarthy
the "real" results massively lost existing info in about the last year. It seems, that a ton of non-AI-generated indices habe been deleted.
1
Link to Source
Expand Replies
Conversation Features
Loading...
Loading...
Conversation Features
Loading...
Loading...
Login
Email or nickname
Password
Remember me
Login
Password Reset
Remote Authentication
Register